by Roslyn Potter
[1] A Kingdom in Perplexitie: Voices of Seventeenth Century Scotland was held at the University of Glasgow on Thursday 11th of June 2026, bringing together researchers from across multiple disciplines including History, Scottish Literature, Theology, Celtic Studies, Archaeology, and History of Art. The conference focus was early modern Scotland, specifically its seventeenth century – a period that has been somewhat overshadowed by the supposed loss of cultural and civic development felt by the Union of the Crowns of 1603. However, as the conference organisers and participants demonstrated, Scotland’s seventeenth century offers much more than the beginning-of-the-century marker has traditionally warranted.
[2] The organising team set out to deliver ‘a symposium with a difference’. With a focus on highlighting the work of postgraduate students and early career researchers, the symposium offered the scholarly community a platform for ongoing discussion on the development of early modern Scottish studies. Roslin Kerr, Pat Mason, Nathan MacLennan, Andrew Colquhoun, and Erin Inglis, all postgraduate researchers at the University of Glasgow, successfully delivered an impressive programme of panels that welcomed attendees from all over Scotland and abroad. As well as individuals at different stages of their academic careers, in attendance were members of the heritage sector and interested public.
[3] The day began with a palaeography workshop led by Stephen Reid (University of Glasgow) which took participants through examples of secretary and italic hand, with a detailed look at letter shaping, common idiosyncrasies, and general advice of what to look out for when approaching early modern handwritten documents. This popular workshop was followed by a ‘pitching session’ wherein PGRs and ECRs were able to obtain direct feedback from a panel of esteemed academics. Professor Stephen Reid (University of Glasgow), Professor Karin Bowie (University of Glasgow), Dr Alastair Raffe (University of Edinburgh), and Dr Margaret Stewart (Edinburgh College of Art) provided feedback on a series of pitches ranging from developing a PhD proposal to structuring an academic monograph. The range of experiences brought by early career researcher Dr Kathryn Comper (University of Edinburgh) and postgraduates Roslin Kerr (University of Glasgow), Cameron Flint (University of Aberdeen), Laura Paton (University of Glasgow), and Alanna MacTavish (University of Aberdeen) were of great value to the listening audience. For those just starting their postgraduate career, it was useful to hear how to approach knotty subject matter, navigate interdisciplinarity, and ethically mediate sources. While a traditional conference paper format showcases new research, the pitching session offered newer researchers the opportunity to gain feedback on more pragmatic elements of research development and delivery. The pitchers immediately secured the respect of the audience who doubtless recognised the courage needed to gain feedback on relatively fresh ideas publicly and in real-time. The academic panel gently yet thoroughly interrogated the pitchers’ ideas, guiding them from various disciplinary perspectives to a cohesive action plan. The aim of the organisers, in this session, was certainly met: the conference theme was investigated; academic excellence was demonstrated; and postgraduate, early career researcher, and professional connections were formed.
[4] The afternoon involved an academic roundtable chaired by Pat Mason. Five specialists across several disciplines including Scottish Literature, History, and Celtic and Gàidhlig studies. Each speaker was presented, in advance, with a strand of the overall conference themes and asked to reflect on the topic from their own perspective: Professor Laura Stewart (University of York) discussed ‘perplexity’; Professor Janay Nugent (University of Lethbridge) discussed ‘creativity’; Dr Aonghas MacCoinnich (University of Glasgow) discussed ‘plural Scotland’; and Dr John Young (University of Strathclyde) discussed ‘connections and exchanges’. Naturally, the conversations overlapped between disciplines, and the broad discussion highlighted key points for the development of early modern Scottish studies. A central theme emerged that praised interdisciplinarity and encouraged collaboration – something that continues to be a challenge in a high-demand field. With fewer opportunities for funding in academia at large, PGRs and ECRs are often in direct competition. A Kingdom in Perplexitie reminded participants that collaboration is necessary and that the field can and does benefit from collaboration and mutual respect.
[5] Overall, A Kingdom in Perplexitie showed that a frank conversation about the direction of early modern Scottish studies is of benefit across the board – from PGRs to Emeritus Professors. The team’s commitment to allowing PGR and ECR voices to be heard and to learn from experienced academics indicates the continuation of an ever-growing community. The day itself highlighted the importance of strengthening inter-institutional and interdisciplinary discussions in what continues to be a time of great perplexitie for Scottish studies as a whole. Building a collegiate network of support through a difficult time for the humanities strengthens the vitality of the discipline and opens the possibilities of interdisciplinary research. A Kingdom in Perplexitie offered scholars a space to meet colleagues, share research, and explore future outlooks with academic rigor and plenty of variety.